After another year of impressively varied catches, we are thrilled to announce the winners of the 2016 Fly For Coarse competition. A judging panel including Matt Hayes and John Bailey had another tough task on their hands. Flyfishing for Coarse Fish author Dom Garnett reports on another exciting year, along with some fresh tips and fly fishing trends for 2016
“While 2016 was a fairly bonkers year on many levels, at least in the fly fishing stakes it was exciting for all the right reasons! For those newer to the Fly For Coarse contest, this was set up in 2013 to provide a different sort of challenge. Bored of the usual “size is all” contest, we wanted to create an event to focus on the “how did you catch it?” rather than purely “how much did it weigh?”
Each year the contest brings fresh surprises and some awe-inspiring catches. 2016 was no exception, with a field of entries perhaps as strong as we’ve ever had! In particular though, it was a year for the rivers, with stunning chub, pike, dace and no fewer than three barbel to our adventurous anglers. So, without further ado, here were our top entries:
Overall winner: John Tyzack (Barbel 12lbs 8oz)
I’m always keen to stress to fly anglers that barbel are well worth targeting. Not easy, but rewarding and the sheer power of a hooked fish is something you’ll never forget. Fishing guide John Tyzack will be known to many of you as a highly accomplished angler- but even his heart must have been thumping with this beast!
Caught on a five-weight outfit, it was tempted on a Scruffy Hare’s Ear, well-weighted and specifically designed to trundle the bottom. John had spotted a “big, dark shadow on the gravels, moving about slowly” and recalls that it “looked huge”. Testing his nymph to get the right speed, he took aim. “It seemed to move in the direction of the fly and pause. I lifted and all hell let loose!” Grateful of tackling up with a robust leader, he managed to beat the fish after five hair-raising minutes. Wow!
John Bailey, himself an avid barbel on fly convert, remarked that the catch “shows that big barbel can be targeted on the fly with magnificent results. This is the perfect antidote to the stereotypical brain dead approach to barbel we see today!” Easy now John… we take your point though. Much more involved than sitting behind bite alarms!
**John’s catch wins a fantastic Peak Fly Tying Rotary Vice (RRP: £169.99). In our opinion the best value quality vice money can buy!
Second Place: David West Beale: Tenkara caught canal pick ‘n’ mix!
While it’s great to see bigger fish, the competition is also all about variety, skill and innovation. David West Beale is certainly no stranger to specimens (he catches some huge perch and was runner up in 2015), the judges loved his experimentation with Tenkara tactics on the Grand Union Canal, an often murky waterway that is perhaps not the most natural choice of fly fishery.
Nevertheless, using his own fly designs, including classic looking flies but also his so-called “Enterprising Worm” tied from Squirmy elastic, he has caught a real assortment of species. Perch and bream are favourites, but he even had a ruffe. And with only short casts required, his Tenkara antics seem perfectly matched to canal fishing. Conventional? No. Fun and effective? Yes!
In fact, David’s catches were first choice for Matt Hayes, who is very much a fan of fly fishing for innovation and pure enjoyment, rather following “the PB and big fish at all costs mentality that is blighting coarse fishing.” He comments: “This angler is not targeting record breakers, but his all-round success and application of a game fishing technique to a completely different environment is fantastic and makes him the stand-out entry in my book.”
Other highly commended entries:
It is almost an injustice for me to describe the other entries as “runners up” because they were all winners as far the the judges were concerned. Every one of them deserved special credit in its own right- as did many other entries that didn’t quite make it (thank you to everyone who took part). So where do we start with the rest?
Meanwhile, we were also delighted to see more young anglers getting out and taking to fly fishing. Ashley Mould was another impressive barbel captor (above), while Bobby Wright deserves special credit not only for his own whiskered specimen, but for a hat-trick of solid barbel, carp and chub (below) all on fly. Great all-round performance!
On the subject of carp, we had some absolute belters in 2016. Dutch entrant Filipe De Clerk claimed a 22lb beauty, while our youngest winner Abbie Fielding had a real fight on her hands with a belter of 18lbs 12oz.
Size really isn’t everything though, and the 2016 list also includes a wonderful dace or Geejay Aitch (below) and some excellent roach and bream from Rutland Reservoir for the Abbott family of John, William and Harry. The panel especially liked Harry Abbott’s emerger-caught roach, which also features on the shortlist of winners.
Here’s a table summing up the best entries. Don’t forget you can see pictures of all the other entries at flyforcoarse.com
Each of our entries wins their choice of a set of flies from the special Turrall Flies for Coarse Fish range (which includes proven patterns for perch, chub, pike, roach, rudd and dace) or a limited edition Fly For Coarse T-shirt!
Further tips, trends and fly fishing lessons for 2017…
Finally, just to whet your appetite for the coming months, here are just a few tips and things to take on board for the coming season:
1. Anything is possible, but only if you try!
How often do most of us leave our comfort zone as fly anglers? It is a good thing to do every season for so many reasons. Not only does it improve our skills, but adds welcome variety to our fishing. The only reason more fish like barbel, zander and even tench are not caught more regularly on the fly is that few people try in the first place.
Some challenges are easier than others, but for just a taster of what can be done with a positive attitude, just look at the Fly For Coarse galleries!
2. Tie your own and try modern materials
Some folks get super fussy about using only traditional, classic materials for their flies. That’s a personal choice, but why miss out? I doubt very much whether the old masters would have turned their noses up at the fantastic materials we are lucky enough to have at our disposal today!
UV materials and special synthetics are all worth a look. But if there is one material that has both caught silly numbers of fish and divided opinion in 2016, it has to be the “squirmy” body material. It’s your call, but squirmy worm style dressings have accounted for many fish of all species, from perch to grayling.
Squirmy body materials might not appeal to the purist, but are excellent for coloured water and adding extra wiggle. We stock three deadly colours.
3. Adjust your timing and pick the best times to go fly fishing
More than ever, we have been getting impressive catch pictures with something noticeably different about the backgrounds. The light is often hazy, soft or downright murky! This is not pure coincidence. The best time to go fly fishing for coarse species -or any fish!- is not when you feel like it, but when they are feeding. Unless it’s overcast or you’re targeting sun-loving fish like rudd, the middle of the day is often not the key time. Experiment on your patch, but do try early or late if you are not getting many takes!
4. Try Tenkara for Coarse Fish!
Modern foibles aside, one of the most noticeable recent fly fishing trends sure to continue into 2017 is the Tenkara bug. Indeed, stacks of fly anglers are enjoying this classic Japanese line-to-hand style of fishing. It’s simple and effective so why restrict your adventures to trout? Fish like chub, roach, rudd and dace are all highly catchable and light Tenkara rods make even small fish fun.”
Fly For Coarse continues in 2017…
With all to play for and so many possibilities, the competition is already on for 2017, with more great Turrall prizes lined up and no doubt more surprises in store. To view all of last years entries and find tips, venues and more on how you can get involved, see www.flyforcoarse.com
Further news and updates throughout the year can also be found in Flyfishing & Flytying Magazine, while fly fishers of all abilities can join the fun on our Flyfishing for Coarse Fish Group Page.
Don’t forget to keep an eye on this blog and the Turrall Flies Facebook page for regular news and tips, besides top quality fly patterns, materials and accessories in 2017!